Originally posted by: orangeh
anything wrong with completely random matches then? Because if the 30th ranked team is playing the 2nd ranked team with how things are now then i dont think random could be worse. Im sure PNW have enjoyed their scheduling thus far (seems they played the same team twice this season?)
i know the twl admins are awesome and are doing their best but realistically theres no way you can make it "fair" for everyone. What are the arguements against completely random? There would be no one to blame for your schedule then
You can get a lot of resentment and backtalk within the community for having a light load. Example, OUF going 7-1 in Season 2 (which I was a part of). My intuition is that people would prefer someone at the reins doing their best to maintain some sort of balance to just a coin flip determining many facets of your season. I could be wrong - I just know how I would prefer it.
The west division always presents its own challenges, and most of them stem from the fact that it never ends a season in anywhere near the form it starts out. Couple that to a number of hassles that come from West teams playing against intransigent Central teams, and eventually you're going to have that matchup. I know there are folks who are used to the season playing out kind of like a playoffs where those matches happen early and the season, and the rest of the season builds up to the playoff-level matches by weekds 6 - 8, but we had resolved to try something else out this season in terms of spreading it out. And with RPI being a major indicator, just getting winnable matches against better than .500 teams is a boon to a team. For balance reasons, the schedulers should be working to get a mix in there. Considering that there are 30 other teams to juggle, all with their own fuzzy "hard" and "soft" schedules, well, sometimes you just go with your gut.
People are welcome to comment either publicly or privately about what you thought of the scheduling in Beta (Skeeve handled Central, I handled East) this season. I'm interested in the feedback for next season.