Back to COD: League

Custom Maps, anyone else feel this way?

Historical capture recovered from the Wayback Machine · captured 2005-05-06 · 14 posts
I'm not one to complain but I just thought I'd throw this out to see if anyone else feels the same way. I'm not here to stir things up and sure people will disagree, but here it goes.

I gotta tell ya, I'm really dissapointed in the map choices TWL and CAL are making.(mostly CAL because TWL follows the lead) All the maps are remakes of overplayed old school games. Granted they probably use them because they play well and have stood the test of time. The Bridge is a cool map but the one used in TWL(sdver) is the crappiest looking map I've played. Inferno and Mill are 16-bit Sega Genesis lookin maps that play well but look friggin rediculous in COD. I play COD because of it's graphics along side of it's great gameplay. I don't want to play maps that have been around longer than my grandmas chin hair. There's an assload of customs out there, why pick maps that look like a 10 year old ported them over. I understand how important it is for maps to play out well in SD, but come on. If I wanted to play CS maps....I would go play CS. Those maps have boxes at every friggin corner, why? because you can shoot through them in CS. When was the last time you shot through a box in COD?

My point is, custom maps are being brought in to freshin things up a bit, which is great but why use old maps if that's the case? I'm willing to bet that almost every team has a player on it that already has spot on strats for those 3 maps. What's so exciting about that?

Solution, maybe have a poll running for next seasons maps. Have everyone throw in some ideas in a thread and take those into a poll. I seen a post over at IWnation where CAL is actively lookin for maps but I'm not sure what kind of progress they are making.
Solution: http://www.teamwarfare.com/forums/showthread.asp?forumid=133&threadid=217178

I missed your input as well as many others' input. We want what the community wants, and we can only gather what you want from the input we get.

S*6|Cougar|TWL
TeamWarfare Lead League Admin
Email: cougar@teamwarfare.com
IRC: #teamwarfare, #twl_cod
well my opionion is this:

I dislike the use of custom maps entirely. They usually are all not even that well done, meaning all the fighting usually takes place at one spot, or other things like that, and thats not even considering the bugs these maps have.

I can play sc_beta1 every now and then but i do not see at all how we are even considering these maps for formal league play. Just my opinion.

i.rev|Cavi|aL*
TeamWarfare Competition Staff
Email: cavi@teamwarfare.com
IRC: #teamwarfare, #twl_cod
"Custom Maps, anyone else feel this way?"

You mean, that they shouldn't be used in competitive play? Yeah, i feel that way.
I think its great to get some custom maps in the rotation, I just wish they would get some with less bugs/exploits in them. I'm not for remade old CS maps though...most of them suck and are horribly remade...I'm so sick of playing the same 6 maps I could puke...its almost like everyone is afraid to play a new gdamn map though...its sad...there are some good maps out there I'm sure.
There are a lot of them that are GREAT SD maps and many servers run them. If you want custom maps drum up the community interest to get them implemented.

TWL|Zepster
TeamWarfare Competition Staff
Email: zepster@teamwarfare.com
IRC: #teamwarfare, #twl_cod
I personally love the custom maps. While some are, indeed, buggy and can be exploited, many are a breath of fresh air. Without custom maps, many players would have left CoD a long time ago. Remember, maps like Mogadishu started out as custom maps as well, and look how enjoyable they can be. I vote yes on proposition custom maps.


Il Nomine patris, et filii, et spiritus sancti.

http://www.ministersofwar.com
I hate the custom maps, not that they arent fun to play, but im too lazy to put them into the rotation and its a b***** doin it anyways, boo customs!
Many custom maps are fun to play, they just take time to make strats for them, and actually "break" into them. Once you play some of the customs for a bit, you will begin to appreciate their originality, and it freshens the game up a bit from the standard maps.

Xfire: alriad | IRC: #MaleNurses | Site: Male Nurses/gA Forums
I'm all for custom maps. Just hoping the community can agree on new ones, not ones used in old games.
Originally posted by: Alriad
"they just take time to make strats for them, and actually "break" into them".


I Total Agree with ya there Alriad. I make maps in my spare time. Im currently working on one now. Im going to call it
MP_WeaponsFactory you can guess what its going to be like from the name, who knows maby you'll get to play in it someday. Point is, Don't Be afraid to come out of your comfort zone and learn some new Freelance maps.

PSss.. I sure like the Map MoH_Bridge for S&D league. It will be intresting to see how it plays in the preseason match.
Practice up!!!!

Maybe you just dont like custom maps because they are different from what you have been playing for the past 2 or so years...in my opinion a change in scenery is fun
Vegas is dead on...lol...customs are great they add life and longevity to CoD. SD is a finicky b*tch though and I think that the only true way to select a custom to add is to juxtapose it to the CoD originals. When it comes to maps copied from other games I have to ask WHY?!

Whats the point...CoD is its own gaming universe. It has an established comunity and benifits not from the incorporation of maps derived from previous titles. These maps...like bridge were designed for a different game...with different dynamics and gameplay. I beleive the CoD community is perfectly capable of creating and implementing its own designs.

What about maps like Amberville_2 a beautiful, complex, and original map, that would open the door for unrivaled strat diversity in its muiltitude of corridors and crossovers?

Lets not water down our community with hacks of other games (particularly ones that can't hold to the graphical standards of dawnville or Carentan...ie bridge). I will follow up with my feelings about winter brecourt after tonights match. TY

DS
Well...I only have one map that I would ever recommend for league play. And that map is here "http://callofduty.filefront.com/file/4_Worlds;30143". This is by far the best made map ever, in my true, completley honest opinion...I mean just look at the setup! I wish I had a rig that could run that

But seriously now, I do agree that somewhere, not yet discovered are some great maps (not ports from other games) that would do really well as an original for leagues. However, crappy made, useless maps, with ceilings that are too short to go under (MP_INFERNO, that stupid ceiling at the stairs...) shouldn't be added.
Post edited by Frosty288 at 4/19/2005 12:54:48 PM

i.rev/ Internal Revolution

14 posts recovered